What would your starting XI be vs Man City?

[Neil_Vaughan]

Robinson

Kelly, King (if fit) Huddlestone, Young-pyo

Lennon, Carrick, Jenas, Murphy

Defoe, Keane

[SurreySpur]

Robinson

Kelly King Gardner Young-pyo

Lennon Davids Carrick Tainio

Mido Keane

[seraphin]

Robinson

Kelly, King (if fit) Huddlestone, Young-pyo

Lennon, Carrick, Jenas, Murphy

Defoe, Keane
100% correct please forward this selection to BMJ

[DonJolSpurano]

-------------Robbo----------------

-Stalteri--Huddelstone--King-- Lee-

---------Jenas--Carrick------------
Lennon----------------------------

------------------------Keane-----
--------Defoe---Mido--------------

[Spur]

Has to start with all three strikers, we have definately played better with all three. Davids out, agree with Neil's defence, but the third striker instead of Murphy.

[sy_uk99]

Has to start with all three strikers, we have definately played better with all three. Davids out, agree with Neil's defence, but the third striker instead of Murphy.

Agree totally - we have to set out for 3 points - We haven't had a decent first half performance for quite a while
Keane can sit behind front two or play opposite flank to Lennon

[rojaskd]

robbo
kelly- king -the hudd- young-pyo
lennon - carrick- murphy/tainio - jenas
mido - keane

[highlander]

Robbo
Kelly--King(if fit, otherwise Naybet)--Huddlestone--Y.P.Lee
Lennon--Carrick--Jenas--Reid
Mido--Keane

Bench:
Cerny
Stalteri
Tainio
Murphy
Defoe

[Robbo1]

Robinson
Kelly
King
Hud
LYP
Lennon
Carrick
Murphy
Jenas
Defoe
Keano

[nuttyhotspurs]

Robinson

Kelly King/Naybet Davenport/Huddlestone Lee

Lennon Carrick Jenas Reid

Keane Mido

[Spur]

Everyone seems to be putting the same thing. This should have been a straight foward question...Anthony Gardner or any other centre half at the club?

[writing_writer]

Robbo
Kelly King Huddlestone Lee
Lennon Jenas Carrick Keane
Defoe Mido

[TomMcLaren]

Everyone seems to be putting the same thing. This should have been a straight foward question...Anthony Gardner or any other centre half at the club?

How about Keano? Got to be a better choice... ;)

[Keanoldinho]

Robbo

Salty King Davenport Lee

Jenas Carrick Davids Lennon

Keane Defoe

[neilmcnab]

without davids ther is no bite in midfield no hussle or even no threat of it happening.. with either murphy or jenus or carrick.. even tho he hasnt been up to scratch of recent as we all no.. lenon has to start..an huddulstone shold be given a go at the back if ledley is fit. and pos salteri.. have to say he safer than kelly, carrick has to show in that dep position he takes and take the ball of right and left backs,,, upfront 3 would be nice but we can only accomodate 2.. at least to start the game..

[neilmcnab]

keanaldo on the right track...:)

[SharX]

Robinson

Kelly King Gardner Young-pyo

Lennon Davids Carrick Tainio

Mido Keane
Agree, although I'd change Davids for Ghaly. I can't wait to see him play. Plus Edgar has been giving nothing but shakey performances lately.:confused: